Previous Page Table of Contents


7. CONCLUSIONS

Overall, the author would caution the Rudjer Boskovic staff against being too “scientific”. Fish farming is still largely an art, not a science, and it is important they keep in mind that the primary goal is fish production rather than scientific research. With this proviso, however, the author recommends that the proposal to develop brackish/seawater cage farming of salmonids in Yugoslavia is sound and deserves support. It will be necessary to make amendments to details of the project document, partly in the light of the above comments and partly because time has passed and the situation has changed since the proposal was written. If possible, however, the author would recommend at least part of the support be given as soon as possible, rather than being further delayed pending revision of the project document.

Table 1
MEAN MONTHLY TEMPERATURE AT DIFFERENT DEPTHS AT THREE SAMPLING SITES IN THE RIVER KRKA ESTUARY DURING 1981 AND 1982
(TEMPERATURE SHOWN IN °C)
LocalityDepth (m)19811982
JulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarAprMayJun
Skradin0.522.323.821.017.412.49.89.27.69.812.515.922.4
"224.027.624.320.015.09.99.511.111.112.616.522.9
"424.024.823.122.620.112.011.813.513.314.017.323.2
"623.223.122.922.719.612.712.313.713.614.616.821.7
Vrulje0.523.624.821.717.710.48.38.97.410.313.118.824.2
"225.226.924.118.414.38.79.29.710.713.419.223.7
"423.624.323.923.018.711.311.312.712.614.518.923.3
"623.421.922.622.318.811.412.012.813.214.917.922.5
Martinska0.523.524.621,418.212.69.97.37.610.512.719.025.2
"223.625.622.320.714.210.38.010.711.112.717.623.6
"423.022.922.021.918.211.111.012.812.014.216.622.3
"622.421.821.721.918.513.211.912.812.414.016.121.7

Table 2
MONTHLY AVERAGE SALINITY AT DIFFERENT DEPTHS AT THREE SAMPLING SITES IN THE RIVER KRKA ESTUARY DURING 1981 AND 1982
(SALINITY EXPRESSED IN PARTS PER THOUSAND )
LocalityDepth (m)19811982
JulAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMarAprMayJun
Skradin0.53.27.23.25.54.12.42.13.66.32.83.43.8
"229.931.826.46.115.32.53.611.411.93.014.46.6
"436.537.035,427.832.28.26.618.933.332.035.125.6
"637.437.436.733.536.424.217.826.238.538.537.130.3
Vrutje0.57.413.717.15.79.27.33.011.410.55.45.17.3
"233.434.125.86.119.47.45.116.313.65.611.08.0
"436.536.334.322.834.415.412.029.332.629.133.826.0
"636.737.136.430.236.718.226.429.737.038.535.430.0
Martinska0.516.321.623.99.319.113,48.116.817.07.910.115.9
"231.830.226.913.427.915.98.921,319.18.917.023.5
"436.437.234.329.135.926.319.626.735.035.035.534.6
"637.036.936.532.736.737.129.729.938.038.837.035.5

Table 3
PHYSICO-CHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) DURING 1982
 0,5 m2 m4 m6 m
DepthTemp.
°C
mg/1 O2S Temp.
°C
mg/1 O2S Temp.
°C
mg/1 O2S Temp.
°C
mg/1 O2S
Month
VII25,49,14,326,59,423,127,17,826,624,88,331,1
VIII24,49,38,026,99,525,325,18,137,024,28,639,0
IX22,28,24,825,38,225,024,77,237,024,06,338,9
X18,910,33,521,39,618,522,87,035,322,86,236,5
XI13,712,23,014,112,210,819,47,130,320,64,737,3
XII11,411,12,712,711,22,716,73,934,017,88,737,0

Table 4
PHYSICO-CHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) DURING 1983
 0,5 m2 m4 m6 m
DepthTemp.
°C
mg/1 O2S Temp.
°C
mg/1 02S Temp.
°C
mg/1 O2S Temp.
°C
mg/1 O2S
Month
I9,312,432,49,712,482,613,47,9526,315,06,3533,0
II8,911,991,09,911,931,111,39,9911,012,67,6922,3
III9,89,962,010,210,962,013,08,7722,413,67,3132,3
IV12,511,922,012,812,492,013,411,9611,914,310,2430,8
V17,311,481,817,411,112,018,310,9631,317,811,4035,3
VI20,39,632,421,110,3911,621,110,4429,820,69,8833,6
VII25,29,252,525,611,9511,723,59,3930,021,98,8035,0
VIII24,18,907,626,49,0415,825,48,8332,024,18,8336,0
IX22,511,334,024,911,2818,025,89,5734,724,67,5937,0
X15,39,427,017,58,3127,021,27,4533,020,86,1935,0
XI11,410,5114,014,89,8919,017,27,3135,017,03,1939,0
XII10,011,4420,011,98,5834,012,57,4938,013,08,3438,0

Table 5
MEAN MONTHLY TEMPERATURES (°C) AT DIFFERENT DEPTHS AT ST. NIKOLA IN THE KRKA ESTUARY DURING 1982 AND 1983
Depth (m)19821983
JulAugSepNovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJul
0.525.623.823.013.910.69.78.510.914.418.921.624.7
225.123.223.317.213.112.712.012.514.318.620.622.7
424.623.023.118.313.714.213.013.014.217.620.022.1
623.922.822.819.014.614.713.412.814.217.719.821.5

Table 6
MONTHLY AVERAGE SALINITY () AT DIFFERENT DEPTHS AT ST. NIKOLA IN THE RIVER KRKA ESTUARY DURING 1982 AND 1983
Depth (m)19821983
JulAugSepNovDecJanFebMarAprMayJunJul
0.525.329.021.015.47.311.014.514.810.813.821.025.6
230.334.335.028.621.219.322.821.017.123.027.231.3
435.037.538.539.526.431.329.534.030.135.333.637.0
634.338.038.038.833.835.337.338.635.836.537.038.0

Table 7
QUALITATIVE STRUCTURE OF PHYTOPLANKTON POPULATIONS IN THE WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) FROM JANUARY TO DECEMBER 1983
SpeciesTrophic status (oligo./beta-meso.)Month
1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.11.12.
CYANOPHYTA             
Lyngbya sp.  + +++++ ++ 
Oscillatoria geminata Menegh.  +  +  +    
Oscillatoria irrigua Gom.  ++++       
Phormidium sp.   +    +  ++
CHRYSOPHYTA             
Chrysophyceae             
Dinobryon cylindricum Imh.    ++   ++  
Dinobryon sertularia Ehr.o            
Bacillariophyceae             
Amphora ovalis Kütz.o-b   +        
Achnanthes brevipes Ag.      ++     
Asterionela formosa Hass.o-b++++++  ++++
Bacteriastrum comosum Pav.  +     ++ ++
Chaetoceros sp. ++    ++++++
Cocconeis placentula Ehr.b++ ++++     
Cocconeis scutelum Ehr.   + +  +    
Cyclotella comta (Ehr.) Kütz.o++++++++++++
Cyclotella kützingiana Twait.b+ ++++ +++++
Cyclotella melosiroides Lemm.    +++++++++
Cyclotella striata Grun. ++ +++  + + 
Cymbella ventricosa Kütz.b ++ ++ +  + 
Diatoma anceps Grun.o++++     +  
Diatoma elongatum Agar.b-o++++++ +++ +
Diatoma vulgare Boryb ++       ++
Fragilaria crotonensis Kitt.o-b +++++  ++++
Fragilaria brevistriata Grun. +++++  +++++
Gomphonema olivaceum (Lyng.) Kütz.b ++   ++   +
Gomphonema olivaceum v. calcareum Cl.b+     +   + 
Melosira moniliformis v. subglobosa Grun.  ++  + + +  
Melosira varians Ag.b+++ +  ++   
Navicula sp.  + +  +     
Navicula gracilis Ehr.b-o++   +      
Navicula radiosa Kütz.o-b ++         
Nitzschia paleacea Grun.  + + + +    
Nitzschia longissima (Breb.) Ralfs     +     + 
Nitzschia sigmoidea (Ehr.) W.Sm.b        +   
Pleurosigma sp.            +
Rhizosolenia alata f. gracillima Grun. ++ + + + +  
Rhizosolenia solterfortii Per.  +      +   
Rhizosolenia longiseta Zahn.o   ++   ++  
Synedra fulgens (Grev.) W. Sm.  +  +   +  +
Synedra ulna (Nitzsch.) Ehr.b+++ + +    +
Rhoicosphenia curvata Grun.b++++++++ +++
Tabellaria fenestrata (La.) Kütz.o-b+ ++ + + + +
PYRROPHYTA             
Ceratium sp.  +  +       
Ceratium fusus v. seta (O.F.M.) Jörgensen  +  +    +  
Ceratium hirundinella (C.F.M.) Schranko    +++++   
Ceratium tripos v. atlanticum Nitzsch.    +  ++++  
Peridinium sp.  + +        

Table 8
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT (EXPERIMENTAL GROUP 5) IN BRACKISH WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) OVER A 5-MONTH PERIOD
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean Length
(mm)
06.01.83.286 35.7125   
08.02.83.2851531866117.321.7
07.03.83.280565232461225.4
05.04.83.274688322902328.9
05.05.83.27041284741524031.0
06.06.83.26191515801062335.3

Table 9
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT (EXPERIMENTAL GROUP 1) IN BRACKISH WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) THROUGH 8 AND 14 MONTHS DURING 1982–1983
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
 
06.10.82.490 4184    
05.11.82.489 651334924  
06.12.82.488 11122794462531 missing
05.01.83.488 1352785426270 
04.02.83.45826175382101403114 missing
07.03.83.446 204458763131612 missing
05.04.83.445 270607149663521 missing
05.05.83.440 323734127533675 missing
06.06.83.4205336800662539315 missing
Experiment completed
06.06.83.100 80800   Growth study carried out on reduced number of fish until sexual maturity
07.07.83.8812849501504417
08.08.83.7117741.04090-10427
08.09.83.683751.110701440
06.10.83.68 831.2151058444
02.11.83.68 1041.53331821480
04.12.83.68 1281.88234924505

Table 10
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT (EXPERIMENTAL GROUP 2) IN BRACKISH WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) THROUGH 8 MONTHS DURING 1982–83
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
 
06.10.82.421 50118    
05.11.82.41011852078935  
06.12.82.409 135330123502771 missing
05.01.83.402 16841888333047 missing
04.02.83.3682918750890193335 missing
07.03.83.36352105787023347 
05.04.83.34412587501724836518 missing
05.05.83.344 32694819868396 
05.06.83.332123441.0368818421 

Table 11
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT (EXPERIMENTAL GROUP 3) IN BRACKISH WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) THROUGH 8 MONTHS DURING 1982–83
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
 
06.10.82.384 76197    
05.11.82.379512031611945  
06.12.82.379 18749317767317 
06.01.83.378 21556976293401 missing
04.02.83.368102266144511350 
07.03.83.36352386564212352 
05.04.83.363 26277712144368 
05.05.83.34233309651884840318 missing
06.06.83.33753481 0346918417 

Table 12
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT (EXPERIMENTAL GROUP 4) IN BRACKISH WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) THROUGH 8 AND 14 MONTHS DURING 1982–83
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
 
06.10.82.166 50301    
05.11.82.16428954324239  
06.12.82.164 13079325041376 
06.01.83.162 150926133203862 missing
04.02.83.15811569876164053 missing
07.03.83.158 1681.0637612419 
05.04.83.15411951.266203274233 missing
05.05.83.153 2181.425159234441 missing
06.06.83.14942421.62920424492 
 Experiment completed
06.06.83.100 1631.629   Growth study carried out on reduced number of fish until sexual maturity
07.07.83.88121531.738109-10497
08.08.83.65231171.80769-36498
06.09.83.65 1211.861544501
06.10.83.65 1352.08021914516
02.11.83.65 1432.2001208530
04.12.83.6411542.40020011541

Table 13
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT FROM EYED EGGS UNTIL 5 MONTHS OLD FRY IN FRESH WATER AT GRACANSKI HATCHERY DURING 1983
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
 
16.1.8312 638 10.09  2.1Eggs
8.2.8311 5701 06820.190.11 Larvae
28.3.8310 65891280.760.6642Fingerlings
27.4.8310 535123242.271.51657 
30.5.8310 49243514.852.62775 
23.6.8310 46626787.452.62784Trouts sent to Novo Mesto

Table 14
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT FROM 5 MONTHS UNTIL 1 YEAR OLD AT NOVO MESTO FISH FARM DURING 1983
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
23.06.83.10.466 787,5  84
29.07.83.10.4541217616,89,3598114
31.08.83.10.4431126125,08,2086134
23.09.83.10.436732531,26,1564148
28.09.83.2.260* 8.176    
29.10.83.2.258211048,717,6341148
25.11.83.2.250812957,58,6919182
28.12.83.2.244614664,97,4617190

* Remaining trouts sent to Skradin for comparative experimental breeding

Table 15
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT IN BRACKISH WATER AT SKRADIN (RIVER KRKA ESTUARY) DURING 1983–84
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean Length
(mm)
 
29.09.83.8.1762.062* (31.2)  (148)Data from Table 9
06.10.83.6.114 20032,7  147 
02.11.83.6.111340466.833,4204178 
04.12.83.5.915196787133,066,9396218 
05.01.84.5.903121.133192,066,4390247 

* Cause of mortality unexplained. After washing the newly impregnated net, the fish were transferred to another location and the situation improved. The reason could be either poison from the impregnated net or some other poison in the water

Table 16
GROWTH OF RAINBOW TROUT STOCKED IN FLOATING CAGES AT DIFFERENT DENSITIES, i.e., GROUP 6: 3.1 kg/m2, GROUP 7: 6.3 kg/m2, GROUP 8: 12.5 kg/m2 AND GROUP 9: 18.8 kg/m2, IN BRACKISHWATER AT SKRADIN
GroupDateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean Length
(mm)
VI04.12.83398 50126  218
05.01.84.3971761936726242
VII04.12.83.796 100126  218
05.01.84.79511491886249246
VIII04.12.83.1.593 200126  218
05.01.84.1.59032941856094244
IX04.12.83.2.388 300126  218
05.01.84.2.384446119468162255

Table 17
AVERAGE CHEMICAL COMPOSITION OF MEAT OF RAINBOW TROUT PRODUCED a) IN BRACKISHWATER AT SKRADIN (KRKA ESTUARY), b) IN FRESH WATER (AT DVOR PRI ZUZENBERGU)
a)
Group
Mean weight
(g)
Mean length
(mm)
water
(%)
Protein
(%)
Fat
(%)
Ash
(%)
Calorific value
(KJ/g)
  I67337373.0619.594.241.34501
  III1 10942671.6519.698.931.22687
b)
  I71038473.5719.156.051.27564
  III1 08643675.0320.894.871.27548

Table 18
GROWTH OF COHO SALMON FROM EYED EGGS TO 8 MONTHS OF AGE AT GRACANSKI HATCHERY (GENERATION 1982)
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight (kg)Mean weight (g)Mean growth (g)Total growth (kg)Mean Length (mm) 
24.02.82.11.448 2,70,2  7Eggs supplied to Gracanski
08.03.82.       Hatching began
18.03.82.11.148300     All eggs hatched
20.03.82.11.148 3,80,30,11,124Larvae
05.04.82.11.005143*14,10,40,10,332Fingerlings
24.04.82.10.926798,00,70,33,839 
07.05.82.10.900269,40,90,21,444 
21.05.82.10.8475315,21,40,55,849 
23.06.82.10.68815933,13,11,717,973 
22.07.82.10.586102*269,06,53,435,986 
30.08.82.10.529.57102,19,73,233,1112 
23.09.82.10.5263124,311,82,122,2110 
25.10.82.10.5215172,216,44,647,9125 
25.11.82.10.51110*3195,918,62,223,6129 

*1 - 50 deformed
*2 - 70 taken for experiment
*3 - squashed during capture

Table 19
GROWTH OF COHO SALMON IN FRESH WATER AT DVOR PRI ZUZENBERGU FISH FARM FROM 26 NOVEMBER 1982 TO 29 NOVEMBER 1983 (GENERATION 1982)
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
 
26.11.82.7.799 14318  128Transported from Gracana
27.12.82.7.770291511917,4130 
27.01.83.7.654116152200,51,8130 
01.03.83.7.5579714719-0.5-5,7132 
25.03.83.7.45310417323425,9133 
28.04.83.7.3051481822516,8158 
27.05.83.4.7582.547161349-18,0164 
30.06.83.4.627131291622913175 
30.07.83.4.361266366842175195 
27.08.83.4.0642974471102580209 
29.09.83.2.360*92871221228234 

* - the loss of 1 695 specimens is unexplained

Table 20
GROWTH OF COHO SALMON PARR IN FRESH WATER AT GRACANSKI HATCHERY FROM 26 NOVEMBER 1982 TO 25 SEPTEMBER 1983 (GENERATION 1982)
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
26.11.82.2.500 4518  12
23.12.82.2.4991481912,613
24.01.83.2.499 552227,313
24.02.83.2.499 6827513,214
28.03.83.2.499 8735819,215
27.04.83.2.496310241614,516
30.05.83.2.4897135541332,518
23.06.83.2.4836166671331,619
26.07.83.2.46914207841740,820
23.08.83.2.45532*2471001639,721
29.09.83.2.42323081262663,623

* 25 specimens taken for experiment

Table 21
GROWTH OF COHO SALMON IN BRACKISH WATER AT SKRADIN (KRKA ESTUARY) AFTER TRANSPORTATION FROM GRACANSKI HATCHERY (GENERATION 1982)
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
6.10.832 525 300119  227
2.11.832 494313291321334236
4.12.832 4841045018149122261
5.1.842 482259423958145281

Table 22
GROWTH OF COHO SALMON IN BRACKISH WATER AT SKRADIN (KRKA ESTUARY) AFTER TRANSPORTATION FROM DVOR PRI ZUZENBERGU FISH FARM (GENERATION 1982)
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean length
(mm)
6.10.832 360 288122  228
2.11.832 3362439216846108251
4.12.832 327959825789207273
5.1.832 326171030548112297

Table 23
GROWTH OF COHO SALMON FROM EGGS TO 6 MONTHS OF AGE AT GRACANSKI HATCHERY (GENERATION 1983)
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean Length
(mm)
 
16.01.83.16.538 4,10,25  7,5Eggs supplied to Gracanski
30.01.83.       Hatching began
04.02.83.13.6052.933     All eggs hatched
24.02.83.13.238367*5,90,450,21,8 Transferred to basins
28.03.83.13.1875116,21,20,710,345Fingerlings
27.04.83.13.69412333,92,31,217,461 
30.05.83.13.54514963,24,72,129,278 
23.06.83.13.48362**93,06,92,229,689 

* -

Table 24
GROWTH OF COHO SALMON PARR FROM 6 TO 12 MONTHS OF AGE AT NOVO MESTO HATCHERY (GENERATION 1983)
DateTotal numberDeathsTotal weight
(kg)
Mean weight
(g)
Mean growth
(g)
Total growth
(kg)
Mean Length
(mm)
 
23.06.83.13.483 936,92,23089 
29.07.83.13.4255817412,96,08092 
31.08.83.13.3893625719,26,383120 
23.09.83.13.3535927320,51,316126Started descaling
29.10.83.13.2837030523,02,532126 
25.11.83.13.2206338329,05,678143Stopped descaling
28.12.83.13.1823831624,2-4,3-67143No food

Table 25
PHYSICO-CHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF WATER IN CRIKVENICE BAY DURING 1983
DateTemperature (°C)pHOxygen (mg/L)Solinity (%.)
11 May9.47.313.13.8
3 June13.27.412.116.9
19 July17.17.510.218.4
2 August18.87.510.117.3
18 August20.07.210.616.5
29 Sptember18.47.19.317.0
26 November12.47.212.413.0

Fig. 1

Fig. 1 Map of the River Krka estuary; showing water depths, siting of experimental rainbow trout and coho salmon farms and sampling stations for physico-chemical parameters of the water

Fig. 2

Fig. 2 Temperature of water at different depths at the experimental cage site at Skradin (Krka estuary) during 1983

Fig. 3

Fig. 3 Salinity of water at different depths at the experimental cage site at Skradin (Krka estuary) during 1983

Fig. 4

Fig. 4 Oxygen content of water at different depths at the experimental cage site at Skradin (Krka estuary) during 1983

Fig. 5

Fig. 5 Growth of rainbow trout in fresh water and in brackish water following transfer of different size-groups of fish to floating cages. (Solid lines are the best and worst mean growth of fish in commercial fresh water trout farms in Yugoslavia)

Fig. 6

Fig. 6 Growth of rainbow trout, of different mean weights at stocking, in cages in brackish water at Skradin (Krka estuary)

Fig. 7

Fig. 7 Comparative growth of rainbow trout (experimental group 1) in brackish and fresh water over a 14-month period

Fig. 8

Fig. 8 Comparative growth of rainbow trout (experimental group 4) in brackish and fresh water over a 14-month period

Fig. 9

Fig. 9 Growth of rainbow trout from eyed eggs to 1 year old in fresh and brackish water

Fig. 10

Fig. 10 Map of the Yugoslav coast from the Italian border to Zadar, showing water depths, positions of operating marine fish farms, and areas of special interest for brackish water salmonid culture in cages

Fig. 11

Fig. 11 Map of the Yugoslav coast from Zadar to Ston, showing water depths, positions of operating marine fish farms, and areas of special interest for brackish water salmonid culture in cages

Fig. 12

Fig. 12 Map of the Yugoslav coast from Ston to the Albanian border, showing water depths, positions of operating marine fish farms, and areas of special interest for brackish water salmonid farming in cages


Previous Page Top of Page