News

Urbanites and mountain smallholders in Peru

25.05.2016

Given the regional geographic specificities of Central Andean valleys, the social and environmental impact of dispersed urbanization on smallholder farmers is particularly high in the new urban peripheries of Peruvian mountain cities. Collaborative planning is seen as a promising approach to achieve sustainable use of the remaining agricultural areas.

Cognitive empathy between local stakeholders in periurban areas of the Peruvian Andes—more powerful urbanites and less influential smallholders—is a helpful ingredient for collaboration at eye level: but are urbanites empathetic toward smallholders and their perceptions of urban expansion? An open-source paper by Andreas Haller of the Institute for Interdisciplinary Mountain Research, Austrian Academy of Sciences, and Institute of Geography, University of Innsbruck looks at this question. He examined whether urbanites living in the new neighbourhoods on the outskirts are empathetic toward the periurban smallholders and their perceptions—advantages (benefits) and disadvantages (negative effects)—of urban expansion.

His abstract continues: Using the example of the periurban Shullcas Valley near the city of Huancayo Metropolitano, this empirical study reveals: (1) the city dwellers’ motives to live on the new urban periphery, (2) how urbanites assess the impacts of urban growth on smallholders and (3) to what degree these assessments conform to the farmers’ perceptions.

The results show that urbanites are mostly empathetic toward smallholders: they clearly perceive advantages and disadvantages, especially the irretrievable loss of agricultural land on the valley floor. However, they show little awareness of the smallholders’ land tenure situation and their dependency on the lease of additional farmland. Consequently they largely overestimate the advantages of rising land prices driven by an increasing demand for lots. The results point to the need for including periurban smallholder farmers into urban planning and call for the creation and/or valorization of cognitive empathy in a preparatory process to collaborative planning—especially in the new urban peripheries of the Central Andes.

This abstract appears on Elsevier’s “Science Direct”, published as part of the “Landscape and Urban Planning” volume.

Download the paper

Read more

Photo: Andreas Haller