5.1 Agenda
5.2 List of participants
5.3 Discussion of FAO Project Framework Proposal
5.3.1 Questionnaire
5.3.2 Evaluation
5.3.3 Documentation of replies
FIRST DAY, MONDAY, 10 MAY 1999
08.30 - 09.00 Registration
09.00 - 09.30 Opening session:
Inaugural speeches by representative of the host country and the FAO Representative
09.30 - 10.00 Coffee break
10.00 - 10.30 FAO Keynote presentations:
From Cairo to Beirut: New developments on NWFP in the Near East in 1997-1999 (Mr Al Fares, FAO-RNE)
Overview on the global FAO NWFP Programme (Mrs Russo, FAO-FOPW)
10.30 - 11:00 Keynote presentation:
The Gum arabic Project and the problems related to the ownership of natural resources (Mr Awouda)
11.10 - 12.00 Country presentations (Part I):
Iran (Mr Mahdi)
Tunisia (Mr Bousaker)
Saudi Arabia (Mr Al Moussa)
12:00 - 13:00 Lunch
13:00 - 13:30 Keynote presentation:
Participatory and integrated forest resource management in the Near East (Mr Kuzami)
13:30 - 14:30 Country presentations (Part 2)
Lebanon (Mr Akl)
Cyprus (Mr Georgio)
Syria (Mr Madi)
14:30 - 15:00 Coffee break
15:00 - 17:00 General Discussion
18:00 - 20:00 Cocktail
SECOND DAY, TUESDAY, 11.05.1999
08:00 - 18:00 Field Trip
THIRD DAY, WEDNESDAY, 12.05.1999
09.00 - 09:30 Keynote presentation
NWFP- Resources and Potential (Mr Baalbaki)
09:30 - 10:30 Country presentations (Part 3)
Jordan (Mr Al Abbadi)
Turkey (Mr
Kizmaz)
Sudan (Mr Awouda)
10:30 - 11:00 Discussion
11:00 - 11:30 Coffee break
11:30 - 13:15 Activities of selected organizations related to NWFP
The WWF Network on NTFP in the Mediterranean (Mr
Moussouris)
NA-SRDC (Mr De Petro)
IPGRI (Mr Van Breugel)
13:15 - 13:45 Coffee break
13:45 - 14:15 Presentation of a framework proposal of a regional project on NWFP in the Near East (Mr Walter, FAO-FOPW)
14:15 - 15:00 General discussion
15:00 Concluding session: recommendations raised and closure
(Mr Al Fares, FAO-RNE)
I. Country representatives |
||||
Name |
Country |
Title/Institution |
Address | |
Mr. Georges Georgio |
Cyprus |
Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry Department |
Nicosia, Tel: 02992141 | |
Mr. Mahdi Imad |
Iran |
Director, Commercialization and Marketing |
||
Mr. Rabah Bouasakar |
Tunisia |
Director, Forest Management,. |
30, rue Alain Savay, Tunis, Tel : 01. 841.686 | |
Mr. Mussa Al-Abbadi |
Jordan |
Director, Forestry Department, Ministry of Agriculture |
Amman, PO Box 2099, Tel: 5337472, | |
Mr. Mustafa Kizmaz |
Turkey |
Director of Research, Ministry of Forestry |
Ankara, Tel: 0090 312 2234505, | |
Mr. Khaled Bin Nasser Al-Moussa |
Saudi Arabia |
Director of Forestry, Ministry of Agriculture |
PO Box 17285, Riyadh, | |
Mr Adul Aziz Al-Jowaid |
Saudi Arabia |
NAWRC, Ministry of Agriculture |
||
Mr. Samir Madi |
Syria |
Forestry Department |
||
Mr. Alhag Melki Awouda |
Sudan |
Consultant |
PO Box 658, Khartoum, Tel : 534308 |
II. Observers |
||||
Name |
Country |
Title/Institution |
Address | |
Mr. Jose L. de Pedro |
Morocco |
UNECA- Forestry officer |
PO Box 316 Tanger, Morocco, | |
Mr. Yorgo Moussouris |
Greece |
Project Coordinator WWF |
Tel: 030 1 7241806, Fax: 0030 1 7241806 | |
Mr. Paulo van Breugel |
Syria |
IPGRI /CWANA |
ICARDA, Syia |
III. FAO |
||||
Name |
Country |
Title/Institution |
Address | |
Mrs. Laura Russo |
FAO/HQ Rome |
Forestry Officer, FOP, Forestry Department, FAO, Rome, Italy |
Tel: 3906 5705 2044, Fax: 39 06 57055618 | |
Mr. Sven Walter |
FAO/HQ Rome |
APO, FOP, Forestry Department, FAO, Rome, Italy |
Tel: 39 06 570 53853 | |
Mr. Adnan Al Fares |
FAO/RNE |
Regional Forestry Officer, RNE, Cairo, Egypt |
Cairo, Al Doki , | |
Mr. Amor Ben Romdhane |
Lebanon |
FAO Representative, Beirut, Lebanon |
Tel: 00961 5 924005/6/7 |
IV. Ministry of Agriculture, Lebanon |
|||
Name |
Title/Institution |
Address | |
Mr. Albert Joukhadar |
Representative of H.E. the Minister of Agriculture |
Blvrd. Camille Chamoun - Galerie Semaan | |
Mr. Ghattas Akl |
Director, Rural Development and Natural Resources Directorate, Ministry of Agriculture |
Tel: 05 455622, Fax: 05 455474 | |
Mr. Fady Asmar |
Head of Service, Forestry Department |
Tel: 03 259818, Fax: 05 455474 | |
Mr. Michel Bassil |
Forestry Department |
Tel: 03 267878 | |
Mr. Fadi Baba |
Agricultural Engineer |
Tel: 05 455630 - 5 | |
Mr. Mazen Kahoul |
Agricultural Engineer |
Tel: 05 455630/35, | |
Mr. Jean Estephan |
Agricultural Engineer |
Tel: 05 455630/1/2 , | |
Ms. Nadine Abdelkhalek |
Agricultural Engineer |
Fax: 05 455620 | |
Ms. Hanadi Jaafar |
Agricultural Engineer |
Tel: 03 705608, Fax: 05 455620 | |
Ms. Fatmeh Beydoun |
Agricultural Engineer, Plant Resources |
Tel: 03 326154, Fax: 01 393860 | |
Mr. Nabil Assaf |
Forest Engineer |
Email: [email protected] | |
Mr. Samir Haddad |
Chef de Cabinet, Ministry of Agriculture |
Tel: 03 380446 | |
Ms. May Rizkallh |
Head, Mont Lebanon Department |
Fax: 05 455623 | |
Mr. Nemr Chalikh |
Agricultural Engineer , Nursery North Lebanon |
Tel: 01 288915/16 | |
Mr. Mohamad Taleb |
Agricultural Engineer |
Tel/Fax: 06 433754 | |
Ms. Lamia El Tawm |
Agricultural Engineer |
Tel: 05 455630 | |
Mr. Marwan Al-Hassan |
Agricultural Engineer |
Tel: 03 633426 | |
Ms. Mona Siblini |
Agricultural Engineer |
Tel: 03 230540 |
V. Agriculture Research Institute Fanar (Tel: 01 882123/5/6/7, Fax: 01 882124) |
|||
Name |
Title/Institution |
Address | |
Dr. Michel Abi Antoun |
Researcher |
Email: iralfnr@cmrs.edu.lb | |
Samir Moussa |
Responsible of Medicinal Plants, Fanar Laboratory |
Email: cralfnr@cms.cdn.lb | |
Dr. Chisto Hilan |
Director, Fanar Laboratory |
||
Mr. Ali Darwish |
Researcher |
Tel: 03 372660 | |
Mr. Michel Hayek |
Researcher, Medicinal Plants |
Email: Grline@sodetel.net.lb |
VI. Other institutions/individuals |
|||
Name |
Title/Institution |
Address | |
Mrs. Efat Abou Fakhr Hammad |
Assistant Professor, AUB |
Tel: 01 350000 Ext. 4493, | |
Ms. Christiane Asmar |
Lebanese University |
Broumana, Tel: 04 862713 | |
Dr. Riad Baalbaki |
Associate Professor, AUB |
Tel: 01 350000 ext. 4507, | |
Mr. Antoine Bekhazi |
Prιsident du Cιnacle Libanais pour la Protection de l'Environnement |
Tel: 01 249018 249020/1, Fax: 09 /780697 | |
Mr. Charles Defrix |
ONF, Union Europιenne, Chef de Projet P.A.P.C.V.L |
Badaro, Tel: 03 322 767 | |
Mr. Charbel El Hanna |
P.A.P.C.V.L Lebanon |
Zouk Mikael, Tel: 09 212190 | |
Mr.Mohamed Gabr |
Chief of the Agriculture Section, UN ESCWA |
Tel: 01 981301, Fax: 01 981510 | |
Mr. Kozhaya Hanna |
Agricultural Engineer, Forestry Sciences,
|
Tel: 03 276943 | |
Mr. Richard El-Riachy |
Agricultural Engineer, P.A.P.C.V.L. |
Tel: 03 326154, Fax: 393860, | |
Mr. Antoine Habre |
Agricultural Engineer |
Bekaa - Rayak, Tel: 03 279573 |
Mr. Georges Khoriaty |
Agricultural Engineer , Chief Editor, AGROTICA - DEBBANE |
Tel: 09 211800, Fax: 09 211797 |
Mr. Michel Khouzami |
National Forestry Consultant |
Tel: 01 329821, Fax: 01 393860 |
Mr. Talih Masri |
Researcher, CNRS |
Tel: 04 409845/6, Fax: 04 409847, |
Mr. M. Hussein Munzer |
Agricultural Engineer, Bekaa - Rayak |
Tel: 03 279573 |
Mr. Kahled Najjar |
Engineer M.S.C., Managing Director, NAJJAR AGRCULTURA & TRADING |
Tel: 01 341190/91, Fax: 01/ 738377, |
Mr. Tony Nehmι |
Journalist - Zgharta |
Tel: 03 272599 |
Ms. Linda Nehme |
Zgharta |
Tel: 03 272599 |
Mr. Roger Saadeh |
House of the Environment |
Monte Verde, Tel: 03 225067 |
Miss Elsa Sattout |
Research Associate (Protected Area Program, Flora Monitoring) GREEN LINE |
Tel: 01 746215 - 09 916015 |
Mr. Hisham Selman |
Manager, Association for Forest Development & Conservation (AFDC) |
Ramlieh, Tel: 03 493281, Fax: 05
/220430, |
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Beirut, Lebanon, 10
- 12 May 1999
Discussion of the FAO Project Framework Proposal
QUESTIONNAIRE
One objective of the FAO Regional Expert Meeting on "The Development and Coordination of Regional activities on Non-Wood Forest Products in the Near East Countries" is the agreement on a draft framework for a regional project on the "Sustainable Development of NWFP in Near East Countries". This project should promote the development of NWFP in the Near East through the
contribution to the conservation and wise management of the regions' forests and rangelands;
provision of income generating activities for the local population; and
development of a general policy framework on NWFP suitable to serve as a model to be adopted by countries and to be integrated into their national forest policies.
In order to take into consideration the country specific knowledge and needs, the participant is requested to answer the following questions by filling out the attached table (see below):
1. Which are the major national topics that should be tackled by a national/regional project on NWFP?
2. Which are the main objectives of the topics chosen under question no. 1 that should be attained by such a project?
Please return the questionnaire to the Secretary of the meeting, Mr. Adnan Alfares or Mr. Sven Walter, by TUESDAY, 11 May, 20:00. The results of this survey will be presented and discussed on Wednesday afternoon.
Example
COUNTRY: Germany NAME: Sven Walter
Question No. 1: |
Question No. 2 |
Remarks |
Major Topic(s) |
Objective(s) to be achieved |
|
Extension |
Implementation of a sustainable management of Gum arabic resources in Southern Germany through the publication and distribution of extension material on Gum arabic exploitation in Southern Germany. |
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
QUESTIONNAIRE - REPLY SHEET
COUNTRY: NAME:
Question No. 1: |
Question No. 2 |
|
Major Topic(s) |
Objective(s) to be achieved |
Remarks |
Please return the questionnaire to the Secretary of the meeting,
Mr. Adnan Alfares or Mr. Sven Walter, by
TUESDAY, 11 May, 20:00
Questions:
1. Which are the two (2) most important national topics that should be tackled through a national/regional project on NWFP?
2. Which are the main objectives of these topics chosen under question no. 1 that should be attained by such a project?
Replies:
The questionnaire was filled out by 90 percent of the country representatives (n = 8) and the totality (n=4) of the representatives of the invited organizations. The major topics that should be tackled through a national/regional project on NWFP according to the replies of the participants are:
Identification and prioritisation of promising NWFP (6n, including concrete examples);
improved harvesting (4n);
Improved marketing (3n)
Sensitisation and capacity building (3n);
Improved processing and conservation (2n respectively); as well as
Improved inventory, cultivation, benefit sharing, production, research and networking (1n respectively).
The questionnaire also identified two major target groups:
The local population (Replies: empowerment of local population, benefit sharing); and
Professionals working in the field of NWFP (Replies: Sensitisation of policy makers, networking, creation of regional forum on NWFP).
Major NWFP and/or species mentioned by the participants which should be included in such a project are:
Resins of Pinus brutia (general aspects);
Gum arabic obtained from Acacia senegal (marketing);
Gum homa (marketing);
Essential oils from Rosmarinus officinalis and Myrtus communis (marketing);
Ceratonia siliqua (Carob) (resource management);
Pinus pinea (edible nuts) and Pinus halepensis (pulp and fibres) (resource management).
Question No. 1: |
Question No. 2 |
||
Country |
Major Topic(s) |
Objective(s) to be achieved |
Remarks |
Cyprus |
1.Improved cultivation and processing |
Assist local communities to cultivate and process NWFP, especially these communities that live in proximity to forest regions (development project) |
|
2. Improved marketing |
Assist local communities to promote products to the international market (marketing project) |
||
3. Improved research |
There is a need for more research (development project) |
||
Iran |
1. New products |
The population is flourishing quickly. Then, FAO must think for their needs, so find some new sources. That is a main objective for us. We must search and find the kind of products (NWF&Range Products), that can be used in the food industry, medicine, etc. Iran discovered a new gum (Homa gum) that is a very good and interesting product that can be used in food industry, medicine, agriculture, etc. |
|
2. Processing |
More important to Near East countries is the question of development of processing with sustainable income in rural areas. |
||
Jordan |
General assessment of the importance of NWFP |
1. To achieve and answer what was mentioned in the questionnaire 2. To train and upgrade knowledge and skills of forest staff in this aspect |
Need a project by donors in order to achieve what is required |
Lebanon |
1. Sustainable harvesting |
Implementation of a sustainable management of Pinus pinea forests in Lebanon including the following topics: 1.1 Improvement of nut production through pruning and fertilisation; 1.2 Grafting possibilities of Pinus pinea and P. halepensis that enlarge the reforestation possibilities of Pinus pinea trees on calcereous hardlinestone geologic formations; 1.3 Highlighting the possibilities of agroforestry in Pinus pinea forests, e.g. Lavandula oil extraction from new cultivated species |
2. Sustainable harvesting |
Implementation of a management system for Pinus pinea and Ceratonia silviqua forests or populations allowing for a sustainable harvesting to support the local needs through pilot plots, appropriate legislation and extension services. This could also be applied to aromatic and medicinal plants . |
||
3. Conservation |
Elaboration of a management plan allowing for both exploitation and conservation through the promotion of intensive farming of the species concerned and appropriate harvesting techniques. This should include an inventory and ethnobotanical studies. |
||
Sudan |
1. Promotion and marketing of already proven NWFP |
1.1 Collection, dissemination and exchange of data, experience and knowledge on a regional and international level 1.2 Development of a promotion programme and a marketing strategy 1.3 Creation of a focal point/forum to co-ordinate and bring both - producers and consumers - together |
To achieve all this, based on a regional study, the formation of a regional body or forum is necessary in order to maintain continuity and sustainability. |
2. Research and Development Programme for promising NWFP |
Categorisation of potential NWFP: Cat I: Research and development is finished and ready to go for the commercial stage Cat II: research is finalised and development stage is required Cat III: Research and development is required |
||
Syria |
1. Project on the identification of promising NWFP |
Data collection on scientific names, economic importance, collection period, population density and the production system (wild/cultivated) |
|
2. Resin production |
Promote the production of resins derived from pine trees (that form 40% of the natural forests), analyse its economic potential, and evaluate the market situation. |
Tunisia |
Development of essential oils: myrtle and rosemary |
Ensure the quality and regular supply through the implementation of a strategy which is based on the following factors: Sustainable management of the resources; Modernisation of the distillation techniques; Prospection of other international markets; Promotion of the national market; Promotion of the transformation units; Support of micro-enterprises specialised on the extraction of oils. |
|
Turkey |
1. Inventory |
1.1 Prepare sustainable forest management plans 1.2 Create income generation possibilities near to the forest |
Firstly, it is important to know which species are there and what is the importance for their income. Secondly, a sustainable forest plan (of the respective NWFP) should be prepared. |
2. Capacity building |
Enable forest staff and local communities (producer) to identify NWFP species and their importance for the local income and the national economy. |
Training should be provided on harvesting, collection, storing and marketing techniques. | |
3. Improved benefit sharing for local communities |
1.1 Improved production and marketing of NWFP 1.2 Capture a greater portion of NWFP value for local resource users through (a) the improvement of harvesting techniques and local facilities and (b) the creation of credit possibilities 1.3 Equal benefit sharing through the establishment of forest development co-operatives |
All NWFP are produced and sold by the co-operative and income is equally shared among the villagers/members of the co-operative. NWFP will be sold directly from producer to the company. |
AUB (Baalbaki) |
1. Marketing and income generation |
1.1 Establish local, regional and international markets for known and currently produced NWFP 1.2 Increase opportunities for income generation based on non-destructive uses of forests |
|
2. Sustainable production |
2.1 Diversify the types and numbers of NWFP 2.2 Promote conservation of existing forests while sustaining or increasing the level of production of NWFP |
||
ECA SRDC (de Pedro) |
1. Sensitization in North Africa |
Preparation of studies, publications of material and organization of seminars, specially that of SRDC-NA, to sensitize policy makers on the need to exploit the NWFP sustainably, as a mean to improve food security in North Africa |
|
2. Networking |
Strengthen networking capacity on information and data generation, analysis and exchange, specially on research, extension and markets among the relevant centres of North Africa |
||
IPGRI |
1. Capacity building |
Increasing the awareness, knowledge and capacity of those with a (potential) interest in NWFP, thus enabling them to (further) develop and increase the utilization/exploitation of NWFP in a sustainable way |
Capacity building can be on harvesting, marketing, processing or on whatever topic there is a lack of capacity. The key element is that people must be aware that it has to be sustainable, and, subsequently, they need to have the capacity to do so. |
2. Research on conservation & use strategy |
Development of conservation & use strategies of NWFP through research based on info such as (a) What are the available NWFP in the country/region? (b) Quantity & quality & potential for income generation of NWFP? (c) Priority setting, (d) to what extent endangered (species and genetic diversity of species) |
Conservation & use strategies come before the development of management plan. It includes: how to exploit the resource (regulated harvesting or producing it outside the natural forest, e.g. plantations, enrichment of forests, etc.) and what measures should be taken to conserve these resources and the diversity. | |
WWF |
1. Environmental studies, yield studies / Definition of sustainable harvest levels |
1.1 Determine the conservation potential of NTFP, i. e. define the positive impact that sustainable management of NTFP has in conservation efforts. 1.2 Integrate NTFP management in conservation projects whereas this is applicable |
|
2. Marketing studies, socio-economic studies |
2.1 Determine the socio-economic potential of NTFP for rural communities 2.2 Elaborate marketing plan for their development in a way to empower local communities to deal with its development in an organised manner that maximises their benefit. 2.3 Define impact of marketing development to community socio-economic patterns, especially in cases NTFP are used at the subsistence level 2.4 Determine action to preserve NTFP importance to community in parallel with marketing development |