Introduction
Agrifood systems play a pivotal role in ensuring the sustainability of biodiversity and enhancing the welfare of communities globally, as they encompass the intricate processes of food production, management, supply, and consumption, all of which are deeply interconnected with both ecological health and cultural practices. According to Cardona Santos et al. (2023), the implementation of national biodiversity programs and action plans (NBSAPs) underscores the necessity to safeguard the livelihoods of small-scale farmers and Indigenous Peoples, who serve as the primary custodians of biodiversity. These communities not only contribute significantly to local economies and food security but also possess invaluable traditional knowledge and practices essential for the conservation of diverse ecosystems. Therefore, recognizing and integrating the perspectives of these communities into agrifood systems is vital for fostering sustainable development and enhancing ecological resilience.
Agricultural land systems are integral to enhancing food security and fostering sustainable development, yet they also significantly contribute to biodiversity loss (Vianna et al., 2021). While agriculture plays a pivotal role in advancing multiple Sustainable Development Goals, it confronts substantial challenges posed by climate change and rising food demand. The Agrobiodiversity Index reveals that, despite many countries achieving moderate action and status scores for agrobiodiversity, they display low commitment scores, indicating an urgent need for more robust policies aimed at enhancing agrobiodiversity across food systems (Jones et al., 2021). In response to these pressing challenges, various sustainable agriculture methods have been proposed, including agroecology, organic farming, and precision agriculture (Çakmakçı et al., 2023), all of which strive to redesign food systems to achieve a neutral or beneficial environmental impact while ensuring food safety and nutrition. However, the successful implementation of these strategies necessitates fundamental changes in agricultural practices and policies, with the overarching goal of protecting ecosystems and biodiversity while meeting the global demand for food.
The aim of this study is to highlight the essential roles of small-scale producers and Indigenous Peoples in conserving biodiversity while emphasizing the necessity of engaging all relevant stakeholders in this effort (Zinngrebe, 2022). Recognizing the intricate relationship between agrifood systems and biodiversity is crucial for policymakers, as it enables the development of effective programs that promote sustainable practices, enhance ecosystem resilience, and empower local communities. Furthermore, the inclusion of Indigenous Peoples not only acknowledges their rights and contributions to biodiversity enhancement but also fosters the involvement of custodians of cultural practices, which is fundamental for fostering collective governance and achieving long-term sustainability in biodiversity conservation initiatives.
Small-Scale Producers visa v Indigenous Peoples Role
Small-scale producers and Indigenous Peoples are instrumental in the preservation of agricultural biodiversity and the promotion of sustainable food systems, as they bring forth extensive traditional ecological knowledge (TEK) honed over centuries of managing their local environments. Their farming practices, which often encompass methods such as crop rotation, the cultivation of native crops, and the utilization of locally adapted livestock breeds, significantly contribute to the resilience of ecosystems. Moreover, by engaging in diverse cropping systems and adopting sustainable agricultural practices, these communities not only enhance biodiversity but also strengthen ecosystem stability, which is critical for ensuring food security in an increasingly uncertain agricultural landscape.
The cultural significance of biodiversity holds profound importance for Indigenous and local communities, as they perceive nature as intricately linked to their cultural identity and spiritual beliefs. This intrinsic connection motivates these communities to actively engage in the protection and management of biodiversity, as their stewardship not only preserves genetic diversity but also sustains traditional landscapes and ecosystems that are essential for the survival of various species. Consequently, small-scale producers and Indigenous Peoples emerge as vital custodians of ecological heritage, playing a critical role in safeguarding the continuity of biodiversity for future generations and contributing to the overall health of our planet's ecosystems.
Small-scale manufacturers play a crucial role in local economies and food systems by providing fresh produce to local markets through indigenous farmers, thereby enhancing food security and nutrition within their communities; moreover, their contributions are integral to the economic fabric of different regions, as they create jobs and support local livelihoods. These farming activities not only sustain the farmers’ families but also bolster overall community resilience. Therefore, it is essential to recognize and support the roles of these stakeholders in agrifood systems to promote sustainable development while aligning with biodiversity conservation goals.
Encounters confronting Small-Scale Producers and Indigenous Peoples
Small farmers and Indigenous Peoples play a vital role in sustaining biodiversity; however, they face significant challenges that endanger their livelihoods and the ecosystems they help preserve. One of the foremost issues is land tenure insecurity, which refers to the absence of formal recognition of their land rights. This lack of legal protection renders these communities vulnerable to land grabs, resource exploitation, and environmental degradation, ultimately undermining their capacity to conserve biodiversity effectively. Consequently, securing land rights emerges as a critical prerequisite for empowering these communities, ensuring their active role in managing and safeguarding natural resources for the long term.
Indigenous people and small-scale farmers confront significant barriers to market access, which leads to their economic marginalization; consequently, many are compelled to establish informal markets due to insufficient resources, information, and infrastructure that hinder their capacity to compete with larger agribusinesses (Jones, Estrada-Carmona, Juventia, Dulloo, Laporte, Villani, and Remans, 2021). These economic pressures not only drive them toward monoculture practices that prioritize short-term gains over long-term sustainability but also contribute to a concerning decline in biodiversity. Therefore, enhancing market access is crucial, as it fosters equitable economic opportunities and encourages small-scale producers to adopt practices that are more conducive to biodiversity preservation.
Climate change presents a substantial challenge to the livelihoods of small-scale producers and Indigenous Peoples, as alterations in weather patterns are resulting in more frequent extreme weather events and shifting pest and disease dynamics, thereby threatening agricultural practices and food security. The vulnerability of these communities is exacerbated by their limited resources and adaptive capacity to effectively respond to such climatic changes. Consequently, it is imperative to integrate programs aimed at enhancing resilience to climate impacts into National Biodiversity Strategies and Action Plans (NBSAPs), as this integration will not only support small-scale producers but also safeguard the biodiversity upon which their livelihoods fundamentally depend.
Position of Stakeholder Engagement
The successful integration of agrifood systems into national biodiversity strategies necessitates the engagement of diverse groups of stakeholders, as their collaboration is essential for fostering a comprehensive understanding of the interconnected challenges and opportunities inherent in both biodiversity and food systems (Zinngrebe, 2022). By nurturing multi-stakeholder partnerships, these groups can effectively pool their resources, knowledge, and expertise, thereby enhancing the decision-making processes to be more inclusive and impactful. Furthermore, a collaborative governance framework not only elevates the voices of small-scale producers, Indigenous Peoples, government agencies, NGOs, and the private sector but also streamlines the formulation of policies that are both equitable and sustainable, ultimately contributing to a robust response to the complexities facing our food and biodiversity systems.
Engaging stakeholders is essential for raising awareness about the importance of biodiversity within agrifood systems, as education and outreach initiatives empower communities and stakeholders to recognize their roles as guardians of biodiversity (Çakmakçı, Salık, and Çakmakçı, 2023). Participation in these programs fosters a culture of stewardship and responsibility, which is vital for cultivating a sense of shared commitment to environmental sustainability. Moreover, a collective effort among stakeholders is crucial for developing innovative solutions that promote biodiversity conservation, thereby ensuring food security and enhancing economic viability. By adopting this collaborative approach, we not only improve the resilience of agrifood systems but also make significant progress towards achieving global biodiversity targets.
The active participation of stakeholders is vital for achieving policy coherence in the agricultural and environmental sectors, as it enables the integration of agrifood priorities into broader biodiversity frameworks. This integration simplifies the alignment of goals and facilitates collaborative actions. A commitment to cross-sectoral teamwork is essential, as it recognizes that the health of agrifood systems is intrinsically linked to the health of ecosystems. By embracing this interconnectedness, stakeholders can collaboratively develop comprehensive strategies that not only support biodiversity conservation but also promote sustainable food production, thereby fostering a holistic approach to addressing these interrelated challenges.
Recommendations
The study proposes the following recommendations to improve agrifood systems in national biodiversity strategies:
Strengthen Legal Frameworks-Governments need to find and enforce robust legal frameworks that protect the rights of small-scale producers and Indigenous Peoples. This will ensure these groups secure land tenure and access to resources. Legal recognition of land rights is vital for permitting these communities and safeguarding biodiversity.
Promote sustainable agricultural practices should incentivize sustainable agricultural practices to promote and enhance biodiversity, for example, agroecology, organic farming, and permaculture. Also, financial and technical support is needed to assist small-scale producers to transition these practices while continuing their livelihoods.
Enhance market access support programs to facilitate market access for small-scale producers, including cooperatives, fair trade initiatives, and value chain development. Improving market access will increase economic viability, leading to the promotion of biodiversity-friendly practices.
Foster collaborative governance-there is a need to create an environment that encourages participatory governance models that include small-scale producers and Indigenous Peoples in decision-making processes related to agrifood systems and biodiversity conservation. This will promote equitable and effective policies that reproduce the needs and rights of these communities.
REFERENCES
Cardona Santos, E.M., Kinniburgh, F., Schmid, S., Büttner, N., Pröbstl, F., Liswanti, N., Komarudin, H., Borasino, E., Ntawuhiganayo, E. and Zinngrebe, Y. (2023). Mainstreaming revisited: Experiences from eight countries on the role of National Biodiversity Strategies in practice. Earth System Governance.
Viana, C.M., Freire, D., Abrantes, P., Rocha, J. and Pereira, P. (2021). Agricultural land systems importance for supporting food security and sustainable development goals: A systematic review. The Science of the total environment, 150718.
Zinngrebe, Y. (2022). Transformative Biodiversity Governance in Agricultural Landscapes: Taking Stock of Biodiversity Policy Integration and Looking Forward. Published online by Cambridge University Press.
Jones, S.K., Estrada-Carmona, N., Juventia, S.D., Dulloo, M.E., Laporte, M., Villani, C. and Remans, R. (2021). Agrobiodiversity Index scores show agrobiodiversity is underutilized in national food systems. Nature Food, 2, 712 - 723.
Çakmakçı, R., Salık, M.A. and Çakmakçı, S. (2023). Assessment and Principles of Environmentally Sustainable Food and Agriculture Systems. Agriculture.
CHAMUNORWA HUNI