Previous Page Table of Contents


Appendix 1
ITINERARIES AND PROGRAMME

A1.1 ITINERARIES AND PERSONS MET

Mr L. Berg and Mr R. Vétillart (Common Programme) 
1–2 August 1988 
Briefing at FAO Headquarters, Rome 
  
2 August 1988 
Departure from Rome. Arrival in Frankfurt 
  
3 August 1988 
Departure from Frankfurt. Arrival in Ankara
Meeting with FAO Representative's Assistant
Mr Bernhard P. Reufels
  
4 August 1988 
Meeting at Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Rural Affairs, General Directorate of Projects and Implementation
General Director
Ichthyologist (Fisheries Division)
Mr Hasim Ogut
Mr Akil Yildiz
Mr Bernhard P. Reufels
Meeting at UNDP Field Office.
Resident Representative
Mr W. Holzhausen
Mr Bernhard P. Reufels
  
5 August 1988 
Departure from Ankara. Arrival in Antalya
Meeting with Project Coordinator (Provincial Directorate of Ministry of Agriculture)
Mr Oktay Atilâ
  
6 August 1988 
Departure from Antalya. Visit to harbour facilities (seaworks) of Antalya, Kemer and Finike. Arrival in Demre. Visit of existing project facilities of the Beymelek Lagoon Aquaculture Centre.
Meeting with President of Beymelek Fishermen's Cooperative

Mr Güngör Kusakgi
Mr Oktay Atilâ
  
7 August 1988 
First survey on project site, lagoon mouth and existing fish barrier, seashore, bathymetry.
Departure from Demre. Arrival in Antalya
 
  
8 August 1988 
Meeting at Provincial Directorate of Ministry of Agriculture.
Director
Deputy Director
Head of Project and Statistic Division
Mr Süleyman Evren
Mr Ahmet Kuzucu
Mr Ginar Aybak
Mr Oktay Atilâ
Mr Akil Yildiz
Project discussion at Provincial DirectorateMr Oktay Atilâ
Mr Akil Yildiz
  
9 August 1988 
Project discussion at Provincial Directorate and meetings at following organizationsMr Oktay Atilâ
Mr Akil Yildiz
Representative of Project and Statistic DivisionMr Adil Bazoglu
Project Manager, Turkish Electricity Company (TEK)
Ministry of Transport
Mr Aykut Taylan
Mr Sadik Köseoglu
  
10 August 1988 
Departure from Antalya. Arrival in Demre 
  
10–14 August 1988 
Site surveys, guidelines for topographical (11–12 August) and pedological (12 August) surveys, preparation of provisional design, cost estimate and interim report 
  
15 August 1988 
Department from Demre. Arrival in Antalya
Meeting with Project Coordinator
 
  
16–17 August 1988 
Meetings at Provincial Directorate - Final collection of cost information and data. Final discussion of project proposal with Deputy Director and Project Coordinator 
  
Mr L. Berg  
18 August 1988 
Departure from Antalya. Arrival in Ankara 
  
19 August 1988 
Meetings at UNDP/FAO Office in Ankara, with FAO Representative
Representative of State Planning Organization
Mr P. Rosenegger
Mr Altan Acara
Mr Bernhard P. Reufels
Mr J.L. Bock
Mr W. Holzhausen
UNDP Resident Representative 
Meeting at the Ministry of Agriculture
General Director of Projects and Implementation

Mr H. Ögur
Mr P. Rosenegger
Mr Bernhard P. Reufels
Mr J.L. Bock
Departure from Ankara. Arrival in Istanbul 
  
20 August 1988 
Departure from Istanbul. Arrival in Milan 
  
19–24 September 1988 
Debriefing in Rome 
  
Mr R. Vétillart  
  
18–22 August 1988 
Final preparation of drawings and technical documents. Meetings at the Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Agriculture in Antalya 
  
23 August 1988 
Departure from Antalya. Arrival in Ankara 
  
24–25 August 1988 
Meetings at FAO/UNDP Offices and at the Ministry of Agriculture in Ankara
Research of local equipment suppliers, especially for centrifugal pumps
 
  
26 August 1988 
Departure from Ankara. Arrival in Rome 
  
29–30 August 1988 
Debriefing in Rome 

A1.2 MISSION PROGRAMME

PeriodProject Steps/ActivitiesPersonnel/Institution Involved
   
August 1988Preliminary mission of experts Outline design, provisional costs, workplanAquaculture/hatchery expert Aquaculture engineer (FAO)
Topographical and pedological surveys Collection of data requiredMinistry of Agriculture NPC, experts (FAO)
   
October-December 1988Survey of lagoon specialist Detailed design for construction Orders of equipment (imported and locally available)Aquaculture experts (FAO) and national staff (Ministry of Agriculture)
Fence installation and control of project site and completion of Directorate buildingMinistry of Agriculture
   
October 1988–March 1989Selection/recruitment of Associate Professional Officers and Senior Aquaculture ExpertFAO
Collection of broodstock and stocking in temporary facilities (if possible)NPC, Beymelek Fishermen's Cooperative
   
December 1988– April 1989Setting-up of all necessary administrative and supervisory procedures for selection of construction companies, work assignments and supervisionMinistry of Agriculture
Provision of financingMinistry of Agriculture
Provision of accommodation for Senior and Associate Professional OfficersMinistry of Agriculture
Preparation of temporary facilities for stocking wild fry (if possible)NPC, Beymelek Fishermen's Cooperative, Ministry of Agriculture
   
April 1989Beginning of construction of farm facilities with first priority for water intake and hatchery (to be ready for operation by October 1989)Construction companies Ministry of Agriculture
Supervision of construction works Beginning of Senior Expert's contract: supervision during construction, coordination, technical tests, etc.Ministry of Agriculture FAO
   
April-October 1989Organization of training to begin by the end of 1989: selection, recruitment, accommodation, etc., of traineesMinistry of Agriculture
Preparation of training programmesNPC, Senior Expert
Organization of fellowships and training abroadNPC, Senior Expert
   
June-October 1989Beginning of hatchery specialist's contractFAO
Beginning of Associate Professional Officer's contract for hatcheryFAO
Start-up of the hatchery (phyto-zooplankton unit)FAO experts and consultants, NPC, national personnel
On-the-job trainingMinistry of Agriculture
   
February-May 1990Start-up of pre-growing/on-growing operationsFAO experts/consultants
Shrimp reproductionNPC, national personnel
On-the-job trainingMinistry of Agriculture
Beginning of Associate Professional Officer's contract for fry collection/on-growingFAO
   
January 1990Beginning of Associate Professional Officer's contract for economics/marketingFAO

Appendix 2
PHYSICAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS

A2.1

A2.1 Project location map

A2.2 Main meteorological data of Demre (4–11 years of observation)

 JFMAMJJASONDAverage/total
Air temperature (°C)             
Average10.510.712.816.119.924.726.726.823.819.714.712.118.2
Average maximum15.814.817.120.425.529.232.132.630.826.020.617.023.4
Average minimum5.24.46.39.513.216.719.219.716.812.19.65.811.5
Snowy days2.22.80.2--------1.26.5
Humidity (%)76717472676258606370797869
Rain (mm)227.2129.6110.332.015.810.70.00.24.160.2113.7204.4908.3
Evaporation (mm)68.069.597.8122.0163.0236.0268.0271.0200.0148.061.867.81 774.6
Rainy days14.610.39.35.42.31.20.10.20.74.88.513.971.3
A2.3

A2.3 Compass card - windspeed and frequency

A2.4

A2.4 Yearly temperature curve of spring and lagoon water

A2.5

A2.5 Yearly dissolved oxygen curve for spring and lagoon water

A2.6

A2.6 Yearly salinity curve of spring and lagoon water

Appendix 3
DETAILS OF THE PROJECT SITE

A3.1
  1. Seawater intake/inlet channel
  2. Brackishwater intake/inlet channel
  3. Mixing reservoir/pumping station
  4. Intensive rearing tanks
  5. Hatchery
  6. Semi-intensive rearing ponds
  7. Water outlet
  8. Service building
  9. Office building
  10. Social building (trainees)
  11. Watchmen buildings
  12. Experts' accommodation building (possible)

A3.1 General layout of the project (1:7 000)

A3.2

A3.2 Hatchery layout

A3.3

A3.3 Layout of the technical service building

A3.4a

A3.4 Seawater intake
       (a) general plan

BEYMELSK LAGOON AQUACULTURE PROJECT
SEAWATER INTAKE

A3.4b

A3.4 Seawater intake
       (b) dikes/cuts

BEYMELSK LAGOON AQUACULTURE PROJECT
SEAWATER INTAKE

A3.4c

A3.4 Seawater intake
                (c) longitudinal outline

A3.5

A3.5 Seawater/brackishwater inlet channels: cuts

BEYMELSK LAGOON AQUACULTURE PROJECT
BRACKISH WATER INTAKE
INTAKE WORK

A3.6

A3.6 Brackishwater intake: plan/cut

A3.7a

BEYMELSK LAGOON AQUACULTURE PROJECT
MIXING/LUMPING RESERVOIR

A3.7 Mixing/pumping reservoir
(a) general plan

BEYMELSK LAGOON AQUACULTURE PROJECT
          MIXING/LUMPING RESERVOIR

A3.7b

A3.7 Mixing/pumping reservoir
(b) longitudinal cut

BEYMELSK LAGOON AQUACULTURE PROJECT
MIXING/LUMPING RESERVOIR

A3.7c

A3.7 Mixing/pumping reservoir
(c) transversal cut

BEYMELSK LAGOON AQUACULTURE PROJECT
INTENSIVE TANKS

A3.8a

A3.8 Intensive rearing tanks
(a) cuts 1.1

A3.8b

A3.8 Intensive rearing tanks and channels
(b) cuts 2.2

A3.9a

A3.9 Semi-intensive ponds
(a) cuts

A3.9b

A3.9 Semi-intensive ponds
(b) cuts

A3.9c

A3.9 Semi-intensive ponds
(c) cuts

A3.10a

A3.10 Fish barrier
(a) general plan

A3.10 Fish barrier module
(b) general plan

A3.10b
A3.10c

A3.10 Fish barrier module
(c) cuts

A3.10d

A3.10 Fish barrier
(d) details

A3.11

A3.11 Lagoon outlet channel: cut

A3.12a

A3.12 Lagoon outlet
(a) general plan

A3.12b

A3.12 Lagoon outlet
(b) dikes/cuts

A3.12c

A3.12 Lagoon outlet
(c) long outline

Appendix 4
TERMS OF REFERENCE

A4.1 Aquaculture/Hatchery Expert (2.5 m/m)
(October-December 1988)

A4.2 Hydraulic Engineering Expert (2 m/m)
(October-December 1988)

A4.3 Lagoon Specialist (3 weeks)
(November-December 1988)

In collaboration with the aquaculture/hatchery expert:

A4.4 Associate Professional Officer
Hatchery/Fry Rearing

Under the general supervision of the Senior Aquaculture Adviser:

Associate Professional Officer
Fry Collection

Under the general supervision of the Senior Aquaculture Adviser:

Associate Professional Officer
Economics/Marketing

Under the general supervision of the Senior Aquaculture Adviser:

Appendix 5
PROJECT COSTS

A5.1 CAPITAL COSTS (LT)

   UNITQUANTITYUNIT COSTTOTAL (× 1 000)
1.ELECTRICITY    
1.1Linekm0 87 500 0006 000
1.2Transformer 400 kVA 117 600 00017 600
1.3Electrical Generators 180–240 kVA 254 950 000109 900
1.4Farm network complete with equipment, transport and assembling   20 000
Sub-total 1   153 500
     
2.SEA DIKES AND LAGOON WORKS    
2.1Sea dikes for lagoon outlet Rocks, complete with load, transport, unloading, placement    
- mixed + 4th categoryt1 1001 9602 156
- mixed + 4th + 3rd cat.t9 6301 96018 875
- 3rd cat.t1 6801 9603 293
- 2nd cat.t9 0202 01218 148
- 1st cat.t10 4752 57827 005
- off cat.t3 1003 062  9 492
    78 969
      
2.2Sea dikes for seawater intake Rocks, complete with load, transport, unloading, placement    
- mixed + 4th cat.t8181 9601 603
- mixed + 4th + 3rd cat.t6 5601 96012 858
- 3rd cat.t1 4001 9602 744
- 2nd cat.t7 0152 01214 114
- 1st cat.t8 0002 57820 624
- off cat.t2 6653 062  8 160
    60 103
      
2.3Lagoon outlet channel    
- digging under water levelm3 5 9402 99117 767
- digging above water levelm3 5 787806  4 664
    22 431
      
2.4Lagoon fish barrier    
- filling upm3 1 5607131 112
- digging under water levelm3 1 2802 9913 828
- digging above soil levelm3 357806288
- water extractiondays6038 4002 304
- bottom regulation/ compactingm215514222
- foundationt1201 960235
- reinforced concrete (350 kg/m3, 130 kg/m3 iron)m377111 0008 547
- footbridge (wood)m407 500300
- grates (flat and V-shaped) 3654 000  1 944
    18 580
Sub-total 2   180 083
     
3.MAIN EARTHWORKS    
3.1Sea water inlet channel    
- digging under water levelm3 3 6562 99110 936
- digging above water levelm3 3 375806  2 720
    13 656
      
3.2Brackishwater inlet channel    
- digging under water levelm3 5 2252 99115 628
- digging above water levelm3 8 075806  6 508
    22 136
      
3.3Earth ponds, dikes and channels (semi-intensive)    
- pond digging over water levelm3190 000589111 910
- channel digging over water levelm314 00080611 284
- dike constructionm3 190 000713135 470
- pond bottom regulation/ compactingm2500 000142  71 000
     329 664
Sub-total 3   365 456
     
4.OTHER WATER SYSTEMS    
4.1Brackishwater intake    
- digging under water levelm3 542 991162
- water extractiondays2038 400768
- reinforced concrete (350 kg/m3, 100 kg/m3 iron)m32598 8902 472
     3 402
      
4.2Mixing/pumping reservoir    
- digging under water levelm3 8102 9912 423
- water extractiondays6038 4002 304
- filling-upm3 300713214
- reinforced concrete (350 kg/m3, 100 kg/m3 iron)m332156 6005 011
    9 952
4.3Distribution channel to intensive tanks    
- filling-up + regulation/ compactingm32 6701 3023 476
- foundationm2 5702 7301 556
- reinforced concrete (350 kg/m3, 100 kg/m3 iron)m3329112 11036 884
    41 916
4.4Concrete tanks (No 14, 2nd year)    
- foundationm2 23124 7005 706
- reinforced concrete ( 350 kg/m3, 100 kg/m3 iron)m3808102 41082 747
    88 453
      
4.5Concrete tanks (No 16, 1st year)    
- foundationm2 8624 0002 064
- reinforced concretem3 408108 82244 399
    46 463
      
4.6Earth tanks (No 10, 2nd year)    
- filling-up (dikes), regulation/compactingm35 5151 3027 181
- bottom regulation/compactingm2 3 800142    540
    7 721
      
4.6Earth tanks (No 12, 1st year)    
- filling-up (dikes), regulation/compactingm33 0201 3023 932
- bottom regulation/compactingm2 1 320142    187
    4 119
      
4.7Discharge channel of intensive tanks    
- diggingm3 3 8808063 127
      
4.8Monks, pipes, grates for ponds and tanks     20 000
Sub-total 4   225 153
     
5.BUILDINGS    
5.1Hatchery    
- building (civil works)m2 1 120136 000152 320
- electrical/heating/ piping systems     164 680
    317 000
      
5.2Directorate building    
- furniture for library room, etc.   20 000
      
5.3Social building (trainees, restaurant)    
- civil works, electricity, heating, waterm2650136 00088 400
- furniture     20 000
    108 400
      
5.4Technical service building    
- civil works, electricity, water, conditioningm2435100 00043 500
- area covered with light roofm212020 000  2 400
    45 900
      
5.5Experts/visitors houses    
- 10 living unitsm2 1 000136 000136 000
- furniture for foreigners     20 000
    156 000
      
5.6Watchmen buildings    
- improvement works to existing building   5 000
      
5.7Electric generators shelterm2 5041 2002 060
Sub-total 5   654 360
     
6.EQUIPMENT    
6.1Pumps    
- pumps of 60 kW, 0.9 m3/sec, H = 5 m 363 800 000191 400
- pumps of 37 kW, 0.6 m3/sec, H = 4,5 m 351 200 000153 600
    345 000
      
6.2Hatchery equipment    
- fibreglass tanks  23 600 00023 600
- pumps  61 400 00061 400
- U.V. sterilizers (Hg - high pressure lamps)  122 000 000122 000
- mechanical filters (sand/diatom) 119 600 00019 600
- air blowers 52 000 00010 000
- oxygen generator 115 000 00015 000
- biofilter mediumm3 12700 0008 400
- tank vacuum cleaner 21 500 0003 000
- homogenizer/grinder 22 000 0004 000
- miscellaneous   267 000
      
6.3Laboratory equipment (in brackets: already purchased)    
- microscopes (1) 22 500 0005 000
- stereo microscopes (1) 21 500 0003 000
- analytical/technical balances (1 + 1) 12 000 0002 000
- oven (1)    
- refrigerator (1) and freezer 2 1 500
- incubator with thermostat/light 12 000 0002 000
- oxygen meters YSI + probes (1) 22 000 0004 000
- pH meter (1) 1300 000300
- salinometers/refractometers (2) 2500 0001 000
- temperature probes 4250 0001 000
- furniture   5 000
- glassware   6 000
- ammonia analysis kits   1 500
- miscellaneous     4 400
    36 700
      
6.4Office/didactic equipment    
- audio-visual equipment (already purchased)    
- telephone central system   20 000
- telefax and telex   6 000
- computer + monitor + printer   4 000
- typewriters   2 000
- slide projectors + screen   1 000
- transparent sheet projector (already purchased)    
- books and periodicals     4 000
    37 000
      
6.5Special equipment    
- automatic data acquisition system   35 000
- 20 m2 chilled room (0°C) + 8 m2 deep freezer (-23°C)   27 000
- ice machine   22 500
- mixers/extruders   18 850
- workshop equipment/tools   5 000
- solar powered feeders (intensive tanks) 150640 00096 000
- weighscales   3 000
- outboard motor boat (already purchased)    
- small fibreglass boats, 3 m 3500 0001 500
- tractor pumps 4500 0002 000
- fishing equipment   2 000
- miscellaneous     10 000
    222 850
      
6.6Vehicles    
- truck for fry transport 3.5 t 125 000 00025 000
- refrigerated truck 3.5 t 130 000 00030 000
- multi-purpose tractor 128 000 00028 000
- tractor and trailer + crane 128 000 00028 000
- small tractor 115 000 00015 000
- minibus (14 persons) 121 000 00021 000
- pick-up 4 × 4, 1.5 t 120 000 00020 000
- cars 212 500 000  25 000
    192 000
Sub-total 6   1 100 550
     
7.CONTINGENCIES (10%)    
Sub-total 7   267 910
TOTAL    2 947 012

A5.2 OPERATING COSTS

(notes to table in the text p. 12)

  1. Personnel
    (See table next page)

  2. Feed

      Biomass increase/year
    (t)
    ConversionTotal feed
    factor (CF)quantity (t)
    1st yearfrom 2nd year1st yearfrom 2nd year
    - sea bass(1 year old)253.5:13:187.575
     (2 years old)753.5:13:1262.5225
    - sea bream(1 year old)153.5:13:152.545
     (2 years old)351.5:11.5:152.552.5
    - hatchery:allow 500 kg at LT 140 000/kg of Artemia cysts
     allow 3 t of crumble feed at LT 3 200/kg
  3. Maintenance

    Assume:  - no maintenance costs in 1989
    - 0.5% of capital costs in 1990
    - 1% of capital costs in 1991

  4. Administration

    Allow LT 20 000 000/year for telephone/telex/telefax expenses

  5. Training

    Allow, from 1990 on, LT 10 000 000/year, for government budget and total LT 127 500 000 (US$ 85 000) from UNDP budget.

  6. Power

    Electricity: Assume following yearly consumptions: hatchery, 240 000 kWh, on-growing 1 250 000 kWh and miscellaneous 220 000 kWh. Total 1 710 000 kWh at LT 43/kWh

    In 1989, only hatchery consumption of 100 000 kWh. In 1990 on-growing consumption of 625 000 kWh

    Heating (gasoline): Assume 100 000 kg/year for hatchery (mainly) and directorate/ social buildings, 20 000 kg for 1989, at LT 400/kg

  7. Packaging/distribution

    Assume for exported fresh product: LT 350/kg of product for polystyrene boxes, nylon sheets, ice and carton + LT 1 600/kg for air cargo to Italy, 75 t of exported fish from 1991. Assume for distribution to local markets: LT 150/kg, 15 t of shrimp in 1990, 85 t of fish/shrimp from 1991.

A5.3 PERSONNEL COSTS

LT (× 1 000) 1989199019911992TOTAL
1. Specialist  m/m m/m m/m m/m  
1.1Centre director162 340126 084127 90965 141 
1.2Hatchery director162 028125 272126 85464 455 
1.3On-growing species161 560124 056125 27363 428 
1.4Phyto-zooplank. spec.161 560124 056125 27363 428 
1.5Economist161 560124 056125 27363 428 
1.6Lagoon spec.161 560124 056125 27363 428 
Sub total63610 6087227 5807235 8543623 30597 347
2. Support personnel  m/m m/m m/m m/m  
2.1Technicians95414 46210837 60210848 8835431 774 
2.2Specialized workers2123 120248 1122410 546126 855 
2.3Workers5307 0206018 2526023 7283015 423 
2.4Watchmen2122 340246 084247 909125 141 
2.5Admin. serv.16585121 521121 97761 285 
2.6Drivers2123 120248 1122410 546246 855 
Sub total2112630 64725279 683252103 58912667 333281 252
Component total2716241 255324107 263324139 44326290 638378 589

A5.4 FEED COSTS

LT (× 1 000)1989199019911992
 Q (t)t (× 1 000)Q (t)t (× 1 000)Q (t)t (× 1 000)Q (t)t (× 1 000)
Intensive rearing         
Sea bass        
1st year fish  87.5105 0007590 0007590 000
2nd year fish    265318 000225270 000
Semi-intensive         
Sea bream        
1st year fish  52.563 0004554 0004554 000
2nd year fish    52.563 60052.563 600
Hatchery         
Artemia cysts0.570 0000.570 0000.570 0000.570 000
Crumble feed  39 60039 60039 600
TOTAL 70 000 247 600 605 200 557 200

A5.5 UNDP CONTRIBUTION EQUIPMENT LIST

1.Hatchery equipmentUS$
- pumps (plastic)44 000
- oxygen generator10 700
- mechanical filters14 000
- tank vacuum cleaners2 200
- homogenizer/grinder2 900
 73 800
   
2.Laboratory equipment 
- 1 microscope1 800
- 1 stereomicroscope1 100
- 1 technical balance1 500
- 1 incubator1 500
- 2 oxygen meters + probes1 500
- 2 refractometers700
- 4 temperature probes700
- 1 pH meter200
 9 000
   
3.Didactic equipment2 800
- computer + monitor + printer2 800
- typewriters1 500
- slide projectors700
- books and periodicals2 800
 7 800
   
4.Special equipment 
- data acquisition system25 000
- mixers/extruders13 600
 38 600
TOTAL129 200

Previous Page Top of Page