全球粮食安全与营养论坛 (FSN论坛)

Consultation

Sustainable agricultural development for food security and nutrition, including the role of livestock - E-consultation to set the track of the study

At its 41st session in October 2014, the CFS has requested the HLPE to prepare a study on Sustainable agricultural development for food security and nutrition, including the role of livestock, to feed into CFS debates at the CFS Plenary session of October 2016.

As part of its report elaboration process, the HLPE is launching an e-consultation to seek views and comments on the following scope and building blocks of the report, outlined below, as proposed by the HLPE Steering Committee. Part A will set the context, drivers and challenges. Part B, exploring pathways, will constitute the greater part of the report.

Please note that in parallel to this scoping consultation, the HLPE is calling for interested experts to candidate to the Project Team for this report. The Project Team will be selected by end January 2015 and work from February 2015 to April 2016. The call for candidature is open until 22 January 2015; visit the HLPE website www.fao.org/cfs/cfs-hlpe for more details.

Proposed draft Scope of the HLPE Report by the HLPE Steering Committee

A) Context: drivers and challenges
  1. The HLPE report will begin with a critical assessment of existing projections of future food demand, including animal-sourced food. It will review projections by FAO and other foresight reports with particular reference to the rapid escalation of the demand for animal-source foods and feed, edible oils and non-food products, including the assumptions which are grounding these projections, on evolution of diets as well as on food losses and waste, and trade.   
  2. The report will then assess implications (challenges and opportunities) of these trends for:
    1. food security and nutrition (in particular nutrient deficiencies, obesity and chronic diseases),  the realization of the right to food, highlighting gender considerations, as well as inequalities;
    2. access to land and natural resources;
    3. agricultural production and productivity increases;
    4. economic development;
    5. the health of the environment and ecosystems, including climate change and biodiversity.

B) Achieving sustainable agricultural development for food security and nutrition

  1. In the light of these projections, the report will review the sustainability challenges for crop and livestock-based agricultural and food systems, including pastoral systems, in diverse agro-ecosystems and for various farm sizes, taking account of threats to the sustainability of these systems, including animal diseases, pest and diseases, and energy needs.
  2. The report will identify objectives and elements of sustainable approaches to agriculture, including livestock, ensuring food security and nutrition for all without compromising the economic, environmental and social bases for the food security and nutrition of future generations. It will identify critical priorities (“tipping points” that need absolutely to be addressed) and objectives. All three dimensions of sustainability will be included and the report will consider relevant metrics.
  3. The report will explore pathways towards sustainable crop and livestock-based systems, and options for managing the transition to sustainable systems:
    1. Given the role of livestock as an engine for the development of the agriculture and food sector, as a driver of major economic, social and environmental changes in food systems worldwide, particular attention will be paid to the role of livestock in these pathways.
    2. The investigation will encompass practices, including agro-ecological practices, diversification at all scales, as well as broader perspectives from food chains to food systems (including consumption patterns), local versus global approaches, trade and investment.
    3. The report will identify barriers to change, including in institutions, organizations, policies and governance, and potential options to overcome them.
    4. It will cover the enabling environment necessary to trigger or accompany transition: the role of public policies and tools to promote and facilitate transition to sustainable systems.
  4. Conclusions and recommendations for policies and actions.
*点击姓名阅读该成员的所有评论并与他/她直接联系
  • 阅读 109 提交内容
  • 扩展所有

Oluwatosin Kennedy Oko

University of Calabar
Nigeria

Good day,

I will be looking forward to participating in the consultation.

Crop and livestock integration will enhance sustainanble food security.

Roger Leakey

None
United Kingdom

Few smallholder farmers in the tropics/sub-tropics grow staple food crops at anything near their potential yield (e.g. maize potential yield is 7-9 tonnes/ha and the average actual yield in Africa is about 2 tonnes/ha). If this yield gap could be filled it would solve the issues of food security, indeed there would be an excess. Filling the yield gap requires better soil/land husbandry (improved soil fertility and soil ecological health), especially as poor farmers cannot afford to buy fertilizers and pesticides. The  use of leguminous trees and shrubs as 2-3 year "Improved fallows" or "relay cropping" can partially restore crop yields (for maize to about 4-5 tonnes/ha), so freeing land for other crops, especially cash crops like fruit trees. The farmer then has the choice to purchase inputs to raise yields to the full potential.

African farmers have suggested that they would like to grow their traditional foods (originally gathered from forests) as new cash crops. After 20 years R&D this is now happening (10,000 farmers in 400 villages) with very exciting livelihood and environmental impacts (see attached), which include the creation of new business and job opportunities for young people and especially women in post-harvest value-adding, and local / regional trade in traditional markets. I have published a highly adaptable, generic 3-step model which I believe to be applicable in semi-arid to humid-zone regions. I believe that up-scaling this approach could resolve the agricultural sustainablity crisis. See also:

 Leakey, R.R.B. 2014. Twelve Principles for Better Food and More Food from Mature Perennial Agroecosystems, In: Perennial Crops for Food Security, 282-306, Proceedings of FAO Expert Workshop, Rome, Italy, 28-30 August 2013, FAO. Rome.

Leakey, R.R.B. 2014. The role of trees in agroecology and sustainable agriculture in the tropics. Annual Review of Phytopathology 52: 113-133.

Leakey, R.R.B. 2014. An African solution to the problems of African agriculture, Nature & Faune 28 (2): 17-20.

 

Dr. Mitiku Eshetu Guya

Haramaya University
Ethiopia

I would like to comment inclusion of pastoral production in a broader way as they are the most economically vulnerable community to different natural, political and manmade shocks and hazards. Moreover, livestock production in the pastoral areas is tradition and focused on livestock number rather than their productivity. This leads to degradation of rangelands and reduces its carrying capacity. Facilities like road, water supply, feed production, veterinary service and market outlet are determinant factors to bring sustainable development in the pastoral areas of East Africa. Combating illegal livestock trade is also one of the major problems that make the pastoralists the least beneficiary from their livestock resources. The local livestock breeds are less productive but well adapted to the harsh environment and the traditional pastoral livestock management system. Giving prior attention for livestock genetic potential improvement through developing synthetic breed seems pertinent for sustainable livestock sector development. Last but not least is animal welfare at slaughter houses and abattoirs. This is critical especially while slaughtering camel in Jigjiga and Dire Dawa town of Ethiopia. In this practice first the camel hind leg is cut at knee to immobilize for slaughtering. This practice is inhumane and very cruel way of immobilizing life animal as the animal is conscious and fully feel the pain. I have attached pictures for your information.

Dr. Shekhar N Ojha

Central Institute of Fisheries Education, MUmbai
India

Gender inequality can be a cause as well as an effect of hunger and malnutrition. A program evaluation from four Asian countries indicated that agricultural training combined with nutrition education empowered women in their ability to offer healthy diets to their families through homestead gardening, while being associated with improved nutritional status. Farmer Field Schools are another practical example of how agricultural development can be both gender-and nutrition-sensitive and complementary to other health-based nutrition interventions. Gender and nutrition are often mainstreamed in Farmer Field Schools, including Junior Farmer Field Schools. There are plans to standardize this approach as part of greater efforts to maximize positive nutritional impact through agriculture.In addition to that, women assume managerial roles at these schools (e.g. presidents, treasurers) with the same frequency as the men. These schools not only directly empower women, but they also enable men to change their view on women. Against this backdrop, following pathways may be chosen to ensure nutritional security through gender mainstreaming, child care programmes and fisheries.

Pathway 1

Women’s participation in aquaculture may have certain effects on improving family nutritional status

Pathway 2

Encouraging women to paricipate in the fisheries related movements

Pathway 3

Organize picnic for  collective feeding session for underweight and malnourished infants under the Positive Deviance (PD) approach, an intervention aimed at reducing malnutrition among children less than three years of age in West Bengal. For twelve days in a month, mothers with undernourished children may follow this regime. This is followed up by an 18-day break wherein care givers monitor the feeding practices in the respective child’s homes and record progress. Every month the malnourished child may be weighed and in most cases, mothers may find their children gaining weight between 100 and 600 gm. A pleasant surprise and a great moral booster for them

Pathway 4

The scope is for an improvement and expansion of food sources in the village school, which is a center of grassroots level in the remote areas.

Pathway 5:

In India there is a need to link Village (Panchayat) Ponds developed under National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS); Village Childcare Centers (Anganwadi) and Village Schools and Earn while you learn for teachers, Women Self Help Groups, Farmers Friends , Farmers Field Schools and students.

faustin KOPANGOYE

Réseau de Living Labs de Developpement Durable et de l'Innovation ( RELLDDI)
Gabon

Bonjour Monsieur,

nous répondons favorablement a votre offre de participation a cette importante question , nous vous transmettrons dans les jours qui suivent un draft sur nos travaux sur le projet pilote de gestion durable de la viande de brousse et de la mise en place des mécanismes de création de la filière viande de brousse en valorisant toute la chaine.

la mise en place des stratégies de valorisation des terres contre l'accaparement des terres par les multi nationales.

et un modele de collaboration entre les populations riveraines et les multi nationales dans le cadre de la Reseponsabilité Sociétale des entreprises.

dans l'attente de savoir si nous avons été retenue , nous reviendrons avec détails pour repondre 

  1. Le rapport analysera ensuite les incidences (défis et opportunités) de ces tendances sur le plan de :
    1. la sécurité alimentaire et la nutrition (en particulier, les carences en nutriments, l'obésité et les maladies chroniques), la réalisation du droit à l'alimentation, en faisant ressortir les considérations liées aux différences entre les sexes, ainsi qu’aux inégalités ;
    2. l'accès à la terre et aux ressources naturelles ;
    3. l'accroissement de la production et de la productivité agricoles ;
    4. le développement économique ;
    5. la santé de l'environnement et des écosystèmes, y compris le changement climatique et la biodiversité.

 

YASSIN MASHUUBU

Ilonga-Agricultural Research Institute (Tanzania)

I would advice the respective authority to include Aquatic agriculture as one of the component of sustainable agriculture. Due to the changing, there  is a need to  direct or develop a theme related to Improved Aquatic agriculture for rural livelihood sustainability.

Yassin Y Mashuubu

HUBERT NDOLO

COPACO-PRP
Democratic Republic of the Congo

La population africaine est nourrie à 75% par les productions provenant des paysans. L'agriculture familiale demeure la meilleure solution pour lutter contre la pauvreté et l'insécurité alimentaire en Afrique. Elle doit être centrée sur les paysans eux-mêmes et non influencée par les politiques au nom et en lieu et place de ces derniers. La subvention des organisations paysannes devrait âtre une priorité pour les gouvernements de nos pays afin de donner un coup de pousse à celles-ci.

Cependant, le constat est très amer, lorsqu'on constate par exemple pour notre pays que, pendant que les Nations Unies décrètent 2014, Année Internationale de l'agriculture Familiale, le gouvernement lance un vaste projet de 23 Parcs Agro-industriels dont le premier à Bukanga Lonzo, a démarré avec un financement de plus de 80 millions de dollars.  Aucune annonce sur ce grand événement depuis le debut de l'année et voilà que nous nous trouvons à sa fin. Il est clair que ce n'est pas la priorité pour le gouvernement.

Par ailleurs, nous avions souhaité que les parcs agricoles soient implantés pour soutenir les efforts des paisibles citoyens paysans répartis dans les environs. On constate toujours qu'ils ne sont pas impliqués sinon pour applaudir lorsque les autorités politico-administratives sont en visite sur le site. Les paysans vont petit à petit être transformés en ouvriers agricoles et par ricochet, perdront leur identité.

Nous avons toujours plaidé pour une implication des dynamiques paysannes en RDC dans les instances de prise de décisions au lieu de les subir.

Ir Hubert K. NDOLO

Bruno Dorin

CSH & CIRAD/CIRED
India

In the attached files (2 page only, published in a little book on deforestation), I tried to present two contrasted visions on the future of agriculture (including livestock) which may be useful to the forthcoming HLPE study and the discussions. I drew on the foresight study "Agrimonde" (scenarios and challenges for feeding the world in 2050) and some other work on structural transformation, employment and labor productivity in agriculture. Visions are part of the drivers and challenges, and they shape our future.

Selina Juul

Stop Wasting Food movement Denmark (Stop Spild Af Mad)
Denmark

Please have this in consideration:

Will minimizing food waste affect the growth of agriculture/farmers?

How will minimizing food waste affect the rest of the food value chain?